Ballot Type: Human
Submitted: Oct. 9, 2023, 9:27 p.m.
Overall Rationale: As a reminder, my methodology is pretty simple; I reward teams who win and drop teams who lose. I’m a big fan of teams who prove themselves against more elite competition and don’t care much for cupcake games, except when there’s something that the cupcake-eater does that merits additional attention. Pretty standard stuff. I’m also a really big fan of poll fluidity and of non-P5 teams, and so my poll may represent overreactions to a given Week’s results, especially early on. Pre-season rankings are nothing but guesswork and failed expectations, anyway. I also try to account for how well teams are doing before and after they play one another, and if there’s anything that’s changed about a team. A lot of it does come down to the dreaded eye test and grinding out wins vs domination, but again, nothing unique. This does mean that I tend to rank pretty harshly by record early on; you’ll see what I mean. Teams Dropping Out: Miami Hurricanes [4-Mario]; Kentucky Wildcats [5-Georgia]; Marshall Thundering Herd [4-NC State]; Notre Dame Fighting Irish [5-Ohio State and Louisville] | Honorable Mentions: Tulane Green Wave [4-Ole Miss]; Memphis Tigers [4-Mizzou]; West Virginia [4-PSU]; Miami (OH) [5-Other Miami]; Ohio [5-San Diego State]; Wisconsin [4-Wazzu]; UCLA Bruins [4-Utah]; Utah Utes [4-Oregon State]
Teams Ranked:
| Rank | Team | Unusualness |
|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Penn State Nittany Lions
|
1.44 |
| 2 |
Ohio State Buckeyes
|
0.18 |
| 3 |
Oklahoma Sooners
|
0.00 |
| 4 |
Michigan Wolverines
|
0.00 |
| 5 |
Florida State Seminoles
|
0.00 |
| 6 |
Georgia Bulldogs
|
-0.40 |
| 7 |
Washington Huskies
|
0.00 |
| 8 |
Oregon Ducks
|
0.00 |
| 9 |
North Carolina Tar Heels
|
0.19 |
| 10 |
USC Trojans
|
0.00 |
| 11 |
Louisville Cardinals
|
0.00 |
| 12 |
Air Force Falcons
|
2.37 |
| 13 |
James Madison Dukes
|
4.45 |
| 14 |
Liberty Flames
|
7.96 |
| 15 |
Texas Longhorns
|
-1.11 |
| 16 |
Alabama Crimson Tide
|
-1.00 |
| 17 |
Oregon State Beavers
|
0.00 |
| 18 |
Ole Miss Rebels
|
-0.01 |
| 19 |
Washington State Cougars
|
0.00 |
| 20 |
Wyoming Cowboys
|
1.22 |
| 21 |
Fresno State Bulldogs
|
4.13 |
| 22 |
Kansas Jayhawks
|
0.00 |
| 23 |
Missouri Tigers
|
0.27 |
| 24 |
Duke Blue Devils
|
-0.65 |
| 25 |
Maryland Terrapins
|
0.00 |
Omissions:
| Team | Unusualness |
|---|---|
Utah Utes
|
1.39 |
UCLA Bruins
|
1.38 |
Notre Dame Fighting Irish
|
0.47 |
Tennessee Volunteers
|
0.53 |
LSU Tigers
|
0.19 |
Kentucky Wildcats
|
0.12 |
Total Score: 29.47