Ballot Type: Human
Submitted: Oct. 16, 2023, 2:36 p.m.
Overall Rationale: Resume based ballot utilizing MoV, SoR, SoS primarily with small amounts of eye-test involved when comparing similar bodies of work.
| Rank | Team | Reason | 
|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Oklahoma Sooners | Best win, undefeated, excellent MoV | 
| 2 |  Washington Huskies | Second best win, undefeated, good MoV | 
| 3 |  Georgia Bulldogs | 3-7 could be put in any order and it would make sense. UGA has a dominant win over kentucky, but some not so excellent showings so far. | 
| 4 |  Ohio State Buckeyes | 3-7 could be put in any order and it would make sense. OSU has the win over ND, which while very good, may not be excellent. | 
| 5 |  Florida State Seminoles | 3-7 could be put in any order and it would make sense. FSU has 2 good wins and ups and downs on MoV. | 
| 6 |  Michigan Wolverines | 3-7 could be put in any order and it would make sense. Clearly dominant defense, but needs strong opponents to prove themselves. | 
| 7 |  Penn State Nittany Lions | 3-7 could be put in any order and it would make sense. Iowa is the best win they have for now, need stronger opponents to prove themselves. | 
| 8 |  North Carolina Tar Heels | Drake Maye is quite good, and they are undefeated. On a power ranking poll, they may not be this high, but on the resume poll they are an unbeaten P5 with a P5 schedule. | 
| 9 |  Texas Longhorns | Strong team, have a decent win against Alabama which puts them as the first of the 1 loss teams | 
| 10 |  Oregon State Beavers | Better wins than Oregon places them in the top ten. | 
| 11 |  Oregon Ducks | Strong showing against a very good UW team, but unfortunately they lost and dont have an excellent win to bump them higher. | 
| 12 |  Alabama Crimson Tide | Bama needs to decide if they like eating glue or not. Not a bad team, but clearly not the elite team weve been used to for so long. | 
| 13 |  Utah Utes | Cam rising will return, one day. Until then, only having one loss and some decent wins is better than i expected for them. | 
| 14 |  Ole Miss Rebels | |
| 15 |  Tennessee Volunteers | |
| 16 |  Notre Dame Fighting Irish | |
| 17 |  Duke Blue Devils | |
| 18 |  Louisville Cardinals | |
| 19 |  USC Trojans | |
| 20 |  Missouri Tigers | |
| 21 |  Air Force Falcons | |
| 22 |  LSU Tigers | |
| 23 |  Iowa Hawkeyes | |
| 24 |  Tulane Green Wave | |
| 25 |  James Madison Dukes | 
Teams Ranked:
| Rank | Team | Unusualness | 
|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Oklahoma Sooners | 1.03 | 
| 2 |  Washington Huskies | 0.00 | 
| 3 |  Georgia Bulldogs | 0.00 | 
| 4 |  Ohio State Buckeyes | 0.00 | 
| 5 |  Florida State Seminoles | 0.00 | 
| 6 |  Michigan Wolverines | -0.62 | 
| 7 |  Penn State Nittany Lions | 0.00 | 
| 8 |  North Carolina Tar Heels | 0.00 | 
| 9 |  Texas Longhorns | 0.00 | 
| 10 |  Oregon State Beavers | 0.44 | 
| 11 |  Oregon Ducks | 0.00 | 
| 12 |  Alabama Crimson Tide | 0.00 | 
| 13 |  Utah Utes | 0.14 | 
| 14 |  Ole Miss Rebels | 0.00 | 
| 15 |  Tennessee Volunteers | 0.27 | 
| 16 |  Notre Dame Fighting Irish | 0.00 | 
| 17 |  Duke Blue Devils | 0.00 | 
| 18 |  Louisville Cardinals | 0.00 | 
| 19 |  USC Trojans | 0.00 | 
| 20 |  Missouri Tigers | 0.00 | 
| 21 |  Air Force Falcons | 0.00 | 
| 22 |  LSU Tigers | 0.00 | 
| 23 |  Iowa Hawkeyes | 0.00 | 
| 24 |  Tulane Green Wave | 0.00 | 
| 25 |  James Madison Dukes | 0.00 | 
No major omissions.
Total Score: 2.50