Ballot Type: Human
Submitted: Sept. 30, 2024, 8:55 a.m.
Overall Rationale: Same as the previous few weeks, although I think my order of conference ranking is now B1G, XII, SEC, ACC, PAC, MWC, American, SBC, CUSA(Unranked Conferences not included in these rankings yet)
Rank | Team | Reason |
---|---|---|
1 | Alabama Crimson Tide | Convincing win over Georgia lifts the Tide back up to #1 in the polls! |
2 | Penn State Nittany Lions | I was really hot on the Illini, and I'm going to take their loss as less of an exposing of them, and more of an impressive Penn State win. |
3 | Indiana Hoosiers | Indiana keeps winning big in B1G games, and I'm not able to keep them out of the upper echelon any longer! |
4 | Oregon Ducks | Good win, now that the teams suspected to be the best are playing real teams, we'll probably see a lot more of them rising up(although look at Ole Miss, maybe not!). |
5 | Iowa State Cyclones | iowa State is looking like the best team in the XII, and earns themselves top five representation! |
6 | BYU Cougars | Although Iowa State is the best, BYU isn't too far behind! |
7 | Texas Longhorns | A good showing from the Longhorns, but other performances outshine them just enough to slow their rise a bit. |
8 | Ohio State Buckeyes | Not a bad game at all from the Buckeyes, but they suffer from similar issues to Texas. |
9 | Navy Midshipmen | Wow. Watching Navy play was something else. Can the defense be worked on? Yes. But, as a former player on a flexbone option offense, is Navy running the scheme to perfection? Yes. Is Blake Horvath a Heisman Candidate? I sure think so. |
10 | Army West Point | Army is moving up, thanks to a similarly dominating performance as Navy had! I have them one below just because I didn't see their whole game like I did for Navy, but the two service academies stay together and move up the ranks! |
11 | Tennessee Volunteers | Victim of the bye, the Vols fall down to #11. |
12 | Missouri Tigers | Same as above. |
13 | UNLV Rebels | Uh, yeah, Skula isn't getting his NIL money. |
14 | James Madison Dukes | Big win, but the strength of the opponent keeps them from rising monumentally. |
15 | Rutgers Scarlet Knights | Rutgers didn't have a horrible game, but it wasn't what I was looking for either. Still, I've got them ranked higher than I suspect most do. |
16 | Miami Hurricanes | That was too close, especially against a team that lost to Vandy. |
17 | Duke Blue Devils | As above, a close game, but Duke survives. |
18 | Pittsburgh Panthers | Can't lose on the bye! |
19 | Liberty Flames | Liberty's forced bye stops the Flames from spreading too much. |
20 | Georgia Bulldogs | Tough, close loss, sadly results in severe punishment this early in the season with my record-based rankings. |
21 | Illinois Fighting Illini | Almost the same case for Illinois, although that loss was a little worse. |
22 | Iowa Hawkeyes | Iowa re-enters, as teams leave with unexpected losses. The bottom four was quite contentious this week, but I think Iowa's the best out of this group. |
23 | Kansas State Wildcats | That Arizona loss doesn't look as bad anymore, and the Wildcats come back into the polls. |
24 | Michigan Wolverines | Michigan is steadily climbing back up, but I don't trust them to stay for too long, unless their pass game improves. |
25 | USC Trojans | Beat the hell out of my choking Badgers? You're ranked! Honorable mentions for this week are Arizona, Boise State, Utah, Washington State, and Notre Dame, in that order. |
Teams Ranked:
Rank | Team | Unusualness |
---|---|---|
1 | Alabama Crimson Tide | 0.00 |
2 | Penn State Nittany Lions | 1.45 |
3 | Indiana Hoosiers | 1.72 |
4 | Oregon Ducks | 0.29 |
5 | Iowa State Cyclones | 1.63 |
6 | BYU Cougars | 0.58 |
7 | Texas Longhorns | -4.35 |
8 | Ohio State Buckeyes | -0.39 |
9 | Navy Midshipmen | 6.98 |
10 | Army West Point | 9.60 |
11 | Tennessee Volunteers | -1.68 |
12 | Missouri Tigers | 0.00 |
13 | UNLV Rebels | 1.29 |
14 | James Madison Dukes | 2.56 |
15 | Rutgers Scarlet Knights | 1.18 |
16 | Miami Hurricanes | -1.42 |
17 | Duke Blue Devils | 0.94 |
18 | Pittsburgh Panthers | 0.92 |
19 | Liberty Flames | 5.79 |
20 | Georgia Bulldogs | -1.68 |
21 | Illinois Fighting Illini | 0.00 |
22 | Iowa Hawkeyes | 2.80 |
23 | Kansas State Wildcats | -0.08 |
24 | Michigan Wolverines | -1.48 |
25 | USC Trojans | -1.36 |
Omissions:
Team | Unusualness |
---|---|
Clemson Tigers | 1.20 |
Ole Miss Rebels | 1.12 |
Notre Dame Fighting Irish | 1.18 |
LSU Tigers | 0.98 |
Oklahoma Sooners | 0.62 |
Utah Utes | 0.50 |
Boise State Broncos | 0.30 |
Louisville Cardinals | 0.16 |
Total Score: 56.22