Back to poll results >>

quantum_jedi Ballot for 2026 Week 12

Ballot Type: Computer

Submitted: Nov. 16, 2026, 1:26 p.m.

Overall Rationale: Resume ranking that evaluates teams based on who they beat/lost to. More points are awarded for beating good teams and less points are subtracted for losing to good teams. Preseason rankings are evaluated based on weighted previous two year's performance, returning production, and team talent composite. Beating an FCS opponent is awarded minimally, but losing is punished. Ranking score is modified by strength of opponent and travel distance to away games. Early season rankings are influenced heavily by strong non-conference wins (e.g., beating two decent teams is rewarded more than beating a single strong team and an FCS team) though this is biased by preseason rankings. Score accumulates throughout the season, so points are awarded based on the models perception of teams at the time. Higher weighting is given to big wins over losses.

I would buy into "SEC cannibalism" more if these games were competitive, but I have no idea who is good since each week is baffling. 11(!) SEC teams in the top 25 this week, but only three make the playoffs. Very balanced bracket at the moment.

Playoff picture according to the model:
#1 Georgia (SEC champ)
#2 Utah (Big12 champ)
#3 Miami (ACC champ)
#4 Indiana (B1G champ)
#5 Texas (at-large)
#6 UCLA (at-large)
#7 Alabama (at-large)
#8 Notre Dame (at-large)
#9 BYU (at-large)
#10 Wake Forest (at-large)
#11 Texas Tech (at-large)
#12 Boise State (top G6 team)

Next five out: Arizona (67.77, -2), Louisville (67.40, +3), SMU (65.58, -2), Houston (65.22, -7), UTSA (63.02, +3)

Rank Team Reason
1 Georgia Bulldogs (115.33, +0) That loss to Auburn is baffling, but also typical Auburn. Georgia is looking far and away the best team in the country right now.
2 Utah Utes (109.46, +0) Absolute banger of a game and Utah pulled off the win over a very good Arizona team. Utah is cooking and is primed for their first playoff appearance.
3 Miami Hurricanes (109.35, +0) Struggling a bit without Malachi Toney over the last few weeks, Miami was able to withstand the onslaught of Nate Sheppard.
4 Texas Longhorns (107.15, +0) What an ugly game and we saw the best and worst of Arch (and the Texas o-line). Texas fans are on a wild roller coaster this year and who knows which team will show up next week against an Arkansas team that is looking to ruin multiple seasons this year.
5 Indiana Hoosiers (103, 89, +1) After a back and forth opening half, the Hoosiers long down USC and pulled away for the win. While Indiana may not be as good as last year's National Championship team, you cannot miss opportunities and hope to beat the Hoosiers.
6 UCLA Bruins (100.62, +1) I'm still not sure if UCLA is actually a title contender this year, but 10-0 and with a chance for the most wins in program history is remarkable! Incredible turnaround and I hope that the Bruins can lock in Chesney for a long time.
7 Alabama Crimson Tide (100.37, -2) The Tide drop slightly this week as UCLA and Indiana notch higher profile wins. At their best Alabama is certainly a top 5 team, but similar to Texas, though not as extreme, Alabama needs to play more consistently.
8 Notre Dame Fighting Irish (94.90, +0) Not much of a game against BC, the Irish seem posed to coast into the playoffs on their signature win over Miami.
9 BYU Cougars (92.97, +0) The Cougars add another solid win over Baylor. That loss to #65 UCF continues to baffle me. I think BYU should still be in the playoff field, but that loss is likely the reason the "Committee" leaves them out.
10 Wake Forest Demon Deacons (92.13, +2) Holy smokes that was a beat down. Jake Dickert has Wake Forest rolling and looking mighty impressive. Incredible coaching job and if Wake wins out I certainly believe they should be in the playoff.
11 Texas Tech Red Raiders (91.97, +0) Very impressive second half for the Red Raiders after an explosion by Oklahoma State in the 2nd quarter. If Texas Tech keeps playing like this then we are in for an epic Big 12 championship game.
12 Tennessee Volunteers (88.31, +1) Not a pretty game, but the Vols slowly crushed a floundering A&M. Tennessee stands on their own in the SEC; not among the elite (plus whatever Texas is), but well ahead of the mess in the middle.
13 Oregon Ducks (85.62, +3) The Ducks look so much more capable on offense since firing Drew Mehringer. The Committee seems to love Oregon so I suppose it's still possible the Ducks could sneak into the playoff by winning the B1G Championship, but that would, at a minimum, require Indiana to lose to either Purdue or Washington, which seems highly unlikely.
14 Ohio State Buckeyes (84.79, +4) Good bounce back win for the Buckeyes over Northwestern. Fahey looks to be improving (possibly?), but still a disappointing season by Ohio State standards.
15 Iowa Hawkeyes (82.32, +0) Iowa seems to be the most "average" ranked team with their best win being #38 Washington, worst loss to #42 Minnesota, and a #20 SOS. Nothing bad, but nothing particularly exciting. A perfectly "Iowa" season.
16 Boise State Broncos (82.01, +1) Great win over Oregon State! Rasean Jones is awesome and deserves significantly more recognition on a national scale. Boise looks to be in pole position for the Group Of playoff spot, and depending on the matchup, could cause some noise.
17 Ole Miss Rebels (80.77, -7) Here begins the cluster of SEC teams that the model doesn't know what to do with. I do not think that Ole Miss deserves to be ranked, but the depth of the SEC is certainly taken into consideration. Not having Lacey is a huge loss for Ole Miss and they look lost without him.
18 Oklahoma Sooners (78.64, +9) Seriously, why is Oklahoma ranked? It's a good thing the model doesn't care about my perception of teams. Perhaps I need to tweak the weights given to wins, losses, and SOS adjustment. The loss to Michigan is looking egregiously bad, but the win over Texas looks awesome. Another one of these SEC teams that I really have no idea if they're are good or not.
19 Kentucky Wildcats (75.37, -5) Kentucky is plummeting back to Earth after their red hot start. Perhaps some of this could be seen by the number of close and OT wins, but Wildcat fans should be thrilled for the future regardless of the last few weeks. The future looks very bright as long as Will Stein is at Kentucky.
20 LSU Tigers (73.77, -1) Some one had to win that game, but add LSU to the burgeoning pile of mess in the middle of the SEC. The Tigers don't have any notable wins (I have #24 Auburn as their best win at the moment), but also no awful loses based on opponent (ignoring the on field product) so who knows what to make of them (sensing a trend here?).
21 USC Trojans (71.24, -1) What an awful place to be for USC fans... Good enough to get your hopes up, but not good enough to actually be competing for anything meaningful. Riley is too expensive to fire and this really feels like purgatory for the Trojans. The "road" game against UCLA to end the season is going to be awesome though.
22 Duke Blue Devils (70.61, -1) Nate Sheppard is awesome. Should he win the Heisman? No, but he definitely deserves more attention and an invitation. Manny Diaz is doing great things at Duke, even if the Blue Devils aren't in the national spotlight.
23 Missouri Tigers (70.06, +0) Ugh, just when I was thinking "Mizzou might actually be good. Has Drink finally figured it out?" the Tigers get utterly dominated by Georgia. Welcome back to the middle of the SEC, Mizzou.
24 Auburn Tigers (68.50, +5) Do I think beating a broken Mississippi State team should count this much? Absolutely not, but the model doesn't recognize injuries. The future looks promising for the Tigers, but for now they join the perpetual motion machine that is the middle of the SEC.
25 Florida Gators (68.25, +6) Really good win for the Gators over Kentucky after two tough losses. Florida is an enigma. They have three one-score wins over ranked teams, plus a bludgeoning of Ole Miss, but all their losses are by multiple scores. Luckily for Florida I think margin of victory is a misleading stat and don't consider it when determining win quality. I expect big things in the future from the Gators.

Back to poll results >>