Back to poll results >>

LookAtMaxwell Ballot for 2026 Week 12

Ballot Type: Computer

Submitted: Nov. 15, 2026, 8:34 p.m.

Overall Rationale: A computer ballot. Monte Carlo of a multiple elimination bracket. Teams are randomly seeded. Wins in the bracket are assigned first by head-to-head performance on the field. Second by transitive wins, third by sampling from the win probability calculated from the colley rating. Teams are ranked first by their median ranking, then by their average ranking. As the season goes on and more of these teams play each other, more matchups will be decided by results instead of simulation.

"but I am not going to massage the model in the middle of the season." I massaged the model in the middle of season. Instead of the simplified score model for simulated games I am using the colley rating win probability. This really only becomes available this late in the season, but it also greatly favors undefeated teams.

Rank Team Reason
1 Utah Utes No losses means no one beats them by rule, and they have the best Colley rating. Their wins over BYU, Houston and Arizona chain into rule wins over Notre Dame, Miami, Tennessee and Texas Tech
2 UCLA Bruins Also unbeaten with no rule losses. They sit behind Utah because they have fewer rule wins (73 to 81) and a slightly lower rating; the win at Oregon gives them Indiana and Iowa by chain
3 Georgia Bulldogs The one loss (Auburn) costs only two rule losses, Auburn and Tennessee. They hold rule wins over eight top-25 teams, including Alabama head-to-head and Texas by chain.
4 Texas Longhorns The most rule wins of anyone (90) and the third-best rating. Two losses (Oklahoma, Florida) leave four rule losses, one of them to Georgia, which keeps them just behind.
5 Notre Dame Fighting Irish The loss at BYU opens chains from Utah, Houston, UCF and Arizona State, so five rule losses despite 9-1. BYU finishes ahead of them in 55% of brackets, but Notre Dame’s median place is better.
6 BYU Cougars Only 11th by Colley rating, but beating Notre Dame gives them rule wins over Notre Dame, Miami and Wake Forest. That lifts them over teams with better ratings.
7 Miami Hurricanes Fifth by rating, but the loss to Notre Dame brings rule losses to Notre Dame, BYU and Utah. Only two top-25 rule wins (Wake Forest, Oregon).
8 Alabama Crimson Tide Lost to Georgia and Tennessee, and loses to Texas by chain (Texas beat Tennessee). Seven top-25 rule wins, all in the SEC plus Iowa.
9 Indiana Hoosiers The only loss is to Ohio State, which lets Oregon, UCLA and Texas (who all sit above Ohio State by results) beat them by rule. Wins over USC and Iowa help.
10 Texas Tech Red Raiders 9-1 with only three rule losses (Cincinnati, Utah, Iowa), but few rule wins (50). With 84 matchups left to simulation, their place rests mostly on their rating.
11 Tennessee Volunteers Beat Georgia by chain and Alabama head-to-head, but losses to Texas and South Carolina create five rule losses, including Utah and Florida.
12 Wake Forest Demon Deacons One loss, to Miami, which passes on rule losses to Notre Dame and BYU. Like Texas Tech, few rule wins (47) and the most simulated matches in this group.
13 Kentucky Wildcats Three losses, but wins over LSU, Oklahoma and South Carolina give five top-25 rule wins. That keeps them ahead of teams with better ratings.
14 Oregon Ducks Losses to Oklahoma State and Illinois open chains to 20 rule losses, the most here. Seven top-25 rule wins (Ohio State, USC, Boise State and others) offset it, which is why their range is so wide (10–31).
15 Florida Gators Four losses and only 21st by rating, but wins over Texas, Auburn, Ole Miss and Kentucky chain into rule wins over Tennessee and LSU as well.
16 Boise State Broncos 9-1 and 12th by rating. The lone loss, at Oregon, drags in 10 rule losses to teams that sit above Oregon by results, and they have no rule wins over a top-25 team.
17 Oklahoma Sooners
18 LSU Tigers
19 Ole Miss Rebels
20 Houston Cougars
21 Auburn Tigers
22 Iowa Hawkeyes
23 South Carolina Gamecocks
24 USC Trojans
25 Missouri Tigers

Back to poll results >>