Back to poll results >>

PlactusTX Ballot for 2026 Week 12

Ballot Type: Hybrid

Submitted: Nov. 17, 2026, 2:19 p.m.

Overall Rationale: First divide teams into tiers, then sort within each tier.

After nearly doing so last week, I vastly reconsidered how I broke down tiers this week, increasing the number to 12. I'll break down tiers 1-7 in the individual team writeups. Tier 8 is the rest of Q1, 9-11 Q2-Q4, and tier 12 is for teams with ratings 500 points below the the average I-A team. (As always, not strict quartiles, but instead I looked for clear breakpoints.)

This is my fourth – and final – version of the ballot. I've tried to catch any mentions of something from previous versions that changed on revisions, but some things may have slipped through. It most definitely is NOT the ballot I had before the Oklahoma/Mississippi game, where I had Mississippi winning.

Dropped out: 16 Mississippi, 19 Louisiana State, 20 Missouri
First five out: Texas-San Antonio, Memphis, South Carolina, Oklahoma, Florida

Rank Team Reason
1 Utah Utes LW: 3 | Tier 1 | W Arizona

Tier 1: Utah

Utah's unbeaten and has a win against a team who, right now, is either in the playoff or the first team out. I can't justify putting anyone ahead of them.
2 Notre Dame Fighting Irish LW: 2 | Tier 2 | W Boston College

Tier 2: Playoff near-locks

Notre Dame has a better win than Georgia, and their loss is also to a better team.
3 Georgia Bulldogs LW: 1 | Tier 2 | W Missouri

Reshuffling tiers knocks Georgia down a couple slots.
4 Miami Hurricanes LW: 9 | Tier 2 | W Duke

I dropped Miami too far after their loss last week and this is making up for it.
5 Indiana Hoosiers LW: 5 | Tier 2 | W Southern California

Indiana's win over USC lets them hold position while UCLA slips a bit.
6 UCLA Bruins LW: 4 | Tier 2 | W Illinois

The good news for UCLA: They'll get their own shot against USC, and then they and Indiana can settle it on the field.
7 Texas Longhorns LW: 6 | Tier 3 | W Louisiana State

Tier 3: The SEC tiebreaker mess

There are two other groups where I threw out resume rankings to sort by head-to-head; with this group I didn't have to, it would've worked out the same anyway.
8 Tennessee Volunteers LW: 7 | Tier 3 | W Texas A&M

And then Tennessee beat Alabama.
9 Alabama Crimson Tide LW: 8 | Tier 3 | W Vanderbilt

Alabama doesn't have the wtf? losses of Texas or Tenneessee, at least.
10 BYU Cougars LW: 13 | Tier 4 | W Baylor

Tier 4: The playoff bubble

BYU benefits from moving up into the new tier...
11 Texas Tech Red Raiders LW: 10 | Tier 4 | W Oklahoma State

...which pushes Texas Tech down a slot.
12 Iowa Hawkeyes LW: 18 | Tier 4 | W Purdue

Iowa is one team I felt I underrated the last couple weeks, and splitting up the tiers lets me correct that.
13 Wake Forest Demon Deacons LW: 12 | Tier 4 | W Southern Methodist

The rating system I used to pre-sort the teams is not kind to the ACC overall, and that has Wake Forest on the outside looking in.
14 Boise State Broncos LW: 22 | Tier 5 | W Oregon State

Tier 5: Boise State

With New Mexico's loss, Boise State now becomes the prohibitive favorite for the G6 playoff spot.
15 Oregon Ducks LW: 15 | Tier 6 | W Michigan

Tier 6: Three-loss teams that can still dream

Realistically, none of the teams left have much chance at the playoffs, but this next large group of teams could make it back in if there's enough chaos – which given the rest of this season, cannot be ruled out. A trio from the Big 10 leads the way, and Oregon beat both of the others.
16 USC Trojans LW: 17 | Tier 6 | L Indiana

And USC beat Ohio State.
17 Ohio State Buckeyes LW: 14 | Tier 6 | W Northwestern

Ohio State is the main reason I split the playoff tiers this week, and I figured I'd push them down a bit. Then this week grabbed the playoff rankings and shook them and lots of teams fell off, while Ohio State held on, and so their drop isn't that big.
18 Kentucky Wildcats LW: 11 | Tier 6 | L Florida

Kentucky got a double whammy: a third loss and their signature win looking a bit less shiny.
19 Duke Blue Devils LW: 21 | Tier 6 | L Miami (Florida)

Losing to a good team plus the chaos all around leaves Duke on my ballot.
20 Houston Cougars LW: 23 | Tier 6 | L Colorado

Probably means I had Houston too low last week.
21 Louisville Cardinals LW: NR | Tier 6 | W North Carolina

An actual winner among all the chaos.
22 Arizona Wildcats LW: 24 | Tier 6 | L Utah

I'm so glad I stayed up to watch this game.
23 New Mexico Lobos LW: 25 | Tier 7 | L Nevada-Las Vegas

Tier 7: Q2 teams with fewer than three losses

This was a late change, after dismantling my spreadsheet to set up for next week. As such, teams in this tier are ranked by the computer rankings I use to set up quartiles. Next week it'll be like all the other tiers.
24 North Dakota State Bison LW: NR | Tier 7 | W Hawaii
25 Liberty Flames LW: NR | Tier 7 | W Middle Tennessee

Back to poll results >>