Back to poll results >>

bladefencer Ballot for 2026 Week 12

Ballot Type: Computer

Submitted: Nov. 16, 2026, 12:11 p.m.

Overall Rationale: Using only results from this year, I compute 1) a power rating, 2) an offensive rating, 3) a defensive rating and 4) a rating from the difference of the offensive and defensive ratings. I use the power rating to compute 5) a strength of record (SOR)/resume rating and 6) a rating that gives very small merits and demerits for particular results (e.g merits for postseason wins or beating a top 15 power rating team; demerits for getting blown out by a team with a similar power rating).

I normalize the six ratings and combine them in a weighted average to determine the final rating which increasingly values the SOR component the further into the season. The weights for the other ratings are static during the season. The result is not normalized, so the best possible final rating is 1.000 if a team is #1 in all six ratings.

Dropped: South Carolina (22 -> 29), New Mexico (24 -> 38), Wisconsin (25 -> 36)

Next 10: Missouri (0.757), Liberty (0.748), Louisville (0.745), South Carolina (0.744), Louisiana Tech (0.743), Northwestern (0.740), UTSA (0.738), Illinois (0.728), Memphis (0.725), Duke (0.724)

Ranking violation % (% of played games with winner ranked below loser): 19.08%
Top 25 ranking violation %: 12.57%

Notes:
* Alabama still somewhat high compared to where I would put them (personally I'd put them around #6-8), but better than the #1 ranking I had them at last week.
* Texas is now higher than I would like (similarly around #6-8)
* Boise is very high (personally #20-25). That their SOS is tougher than Wake Forest really calls into question my SOS methodology. Wake hasn't had the toughest schedule but at least played Miami, Louisville and SMU. Boise St has really only played Oregon.
* Kentucky with their blowout losses and scraping by OT wins feels a bit too high as well (personally #18-20)
* The 4 loss SEC teams feel quite high. I'm my personal rating the 4 loss teams would slide in favor of Arizona, Houston, Louisville and Duke with maybe Florida and Auburn just still ranked due to their wins over Texas and Georgia respectively and no disqualifying losses (e.g. Michigan or Arkansas)

Rank Team Reason
1 Georgia Bulldogs 0.966, +1, Pow: 1, Off: 1, Def: 9, SOR: 2
2 Utah Utes 0.962, +1, Pow: 5, Off: 7, Def: 20, SOR: 1
3 Texas Longhorns 0.940, +3, Pow: 4, Off: 15, Def: 1, SOR: 3
4 Alabama Crimson Tide 0.931, -3, Pow: 2, Off: 4, Def: 5, SOR: 5
5 UCLA Bruins 0.915, +0, Pow: 9, Off: 26, Def: 10, SOR: 4
6 Notre Dame Fighting Irish 0.914, -2, Pow: 3, Off: 6, Def: 6, SOR: 7
7 Miami Hurricanes 0.913, +0, Pow: 8, Off: 2, Def: 35, SOR: 6
8 Tennessee Volunteers 0.888, +1, Pow: 6, Off: 18, Def: 4, SOR: 11
9 Indiana Hoosiers 0.877, +1, Pow: 16, Off: 39, Def: 3, SOR: 8
10 Wake Forest Demon Deacons 0.871, +3, Pow: 18, Off: 8, Def: 17, SOR: 13
11 Texas Tech Red Raiders 0.868, +3, Pow: 13, Off: 11, Def: 43, SOR: 9
12 Boise State Broncos 0.864, -1, Pow: 11, Off: 12, Def: 59, SOR: 10
13 BYU Cougars 0.857, +2, Pow: 17, Off: 36, Def: 11, SOR: 12
14 Oregon Ducks 0.854, -2, Pow: 12, Off: 13, Def: 15, SOR: 14
15 Ohio State Buckeyes 0.832, +6, Pow: 10, Off: 9, Def: 18, SOR: 16
16 Kentucky Wildcats 0.827, -8, Pow: 23, Off: 27, Def: 28, SOR: 15
17 Iowa Hawkeyes 0.826, +2, Pow: 20, Off: 48, Def: 2, SOR: 17
18 Ole Miss Rebels 0.798, -1, Pow: 14, Off: 10, Def: 27, SOR: 18
19 USC Trojans 0.794, +1, Pow: 29, Off: 22, Def: 48, SOR: 20
20 LSU Tigers 0.794, -4, Pow: 7, Off: 5, Def: 16, SOR: 29
21 Florida Gators 0.792, +5, Pow: 27, Off: 21, Def: 30, SOR: 21
22 Auburn Tigers 0.790, +9, Pow: 30, Off: 38, Def: 21, SOR: 22
23 Arizona Wildcats 0.783, +0, Pow: 15, Off: 20, Def: 32, SOR: 26
24 Oklahoma Sooners 0.773, +4, Pow: 32, Off: 62, Def: 7, SOR: 27
25 Houston Cougars 0.770, -7, Pow: 26, Off: 24, Def: 33, SOR: 25

Back to poll results >>