Ballot Type: Human
Submitted: Nov. 26, 2024, 9:57 a.m.
Overall Rationale: LINK TO FULL EXPLANATIONS AND PREVIOUS RANKINGS: https://docs.google.com/document/d/12hrSkt8O3xI3DLURD-kJ7eDSzzipjA97_UZ_NzAjpYk/edit?usp=sharing (eventually I'll catch back up... maybe) | This is a highly resume-based and record-based poll. I give some extra love to the G5 programs relative to more official polling, but otherwise I do my best to maintain a strict adherence to what a team has done regardless of talent or pre-season perceptions. Statistics like Strength of Schedule (SOS), Strength of Record (SOR), and Game Control (GC) will be included in rankings - deviations from these will be explained if necessary. All stats included are courtesy of ESPN - https://www.espn.com/college-football/fpi/_/view/resume - unless stated otherwise. | Each team (if possible) has been listed with their SOS, SOR, and ranked wins and losses. All losses are included. Victories against teams in the "Dropping Out" or "Honorable Mentions" sections are included. In the absence of a favorable result against anyone in the top 35, a team's best win (either by personal judgment or statistical analysis) will be put forth instead. ||| Honorable Mentions: Missouri [8-3, 4-3 in conference play], Memphis [9-2, 5-2], Syracuse [8-3, 4-3], Louisiana (Lafayette) [9-2, 6-1], Duke [8-3, 4-3], Georgia Tech [7-4, 5-3], Jacksonville State [8-3, 7-0], Ohio [8-3, 6-1] | Dropping Out: #25 Washington State [8-3, 0-1] |||
Rank | Team | Reason |
---|---|---|
1 | Oregon Ducks | [11-0, 8-0 in conference play] (-) | Strength of Schedule (SOS): #52 | Strength of Record (SOR): #1 | Best Wins: 32-31 vs #2 Ohio State, 37-34 vs #8 Boise State, 38-9 vs #24 Illinois | Losses: None | Additional Notes: Clinched B1G Title Game berth |
2 | Ohio State Buckeyes | [10-1, 7-1] (+1) | SOS: #25 | SOR: #3 | Best Wins: 20-13 @ #6 Penn State, 38-15 vs #9 Indiana | Losses: 31-32 @ #1 Ohio State | Additional Notes: |
3 | Notre Dame Fighting Irish | [10-1, 0w0 no conference? but still 5-0 against the ACC] (+1) | SOS: #78 | SOR: #10 | Best Wins: 23-13 @ #22 Texas A&M, 49-14 vs #23 Army (neutral site, Yankee Stadium), 31-24 vs Louisville, 31-13 vs Georgia Tech ("neutral site", Atlanta) | Losses: 14-16 vs Unranked Northern Illinois [6-5] | Additional Notes: #6 in Game Control and #1 in AVGWP |
4 | SMU Mustangs | [10-1, 8-0] (+5) | SOS: #77 | SOR: #9 | Best Wins: 34-27 @ Louisville, 28-27 (OT) @ Duke | Losses: 15-18 vs #13 BYU | Additional Notes: Clinched ACC Title Game Berth |
5 | Texas Longhorns | [10-1, 6-1] (+2) | SOS: #36 | SOR: #5 | Best Wins: 31-12 @ Michigan [6-5], 34-3 vs Oklahoma (RRS, Cotton Bowl) [6-5], 49-17 vs Florida [6-5]| Losses: 15-30 vs #10 Georgia | Additional Notes: Clinches SEC Title Game Berth with win @ Texas A&M |
6 | Penn State Nittany Lions | [10-1, 7-1] (-1) | SOS: #32 | SOR: #4 | Best Wins: 21-7 vs #24 Illinois | Losses: 13-20 vs #2 Ohio State | Additional Notes: https://giphy.com/gifs/rally-joe-biden-super-tuesday-ftTdN4slQhMKi4KNO0 |
7 | Miami Hurricanes | [10-1, 6-1] (+3) | SOS: #59 | SOR: #6 | Best Wins: 52-45 @ Louisville, 53-31 vs Duke | Losses: 23-28 @ Georgia Tech | Additional Notes: Clinches ACC Title Game Berth with win @ Syracuse |
8 | Boise State Broncos | [10-1, 7-0] (-2) | SOS: #81 | SOR: #12 | Best Wins: 29-24 @ #21 UNLV, 45-24 vs Washington State | Losses: 34-37 @ #1 Oregon | Additional Notes: Clinched MWC Title Game Berth |
9 | Indiana Hoosiers | [10-1, 7-1] (-7) | SOS: #51 | SOR: #7 | Best Wins: 56-7 vs Nebraska [6-5] | Losses: 15-38 @ #2 Ohio State | Additional Notes: Have only trailed in two games - @ Michigan State [5-6] (won 47-10) and @ #2 Ohio State |
10 | Georgia Bulldogs | [9-2, 6-2] (+1) | SOS: #1 | SOR: #2 | Best Wins: 30-15 @ #5 Texas, 31-17 vs #11 Tennessee, 34-3 vs #14 Clemson ("neutral site", Atlanta) | Losses: 34-41 @ #20 Alabama, 10-28 @ #18 Ole Miss | Additional Notes: Clinched SEC Title Game Berth |
11 | Tennessee Volunteers | [9-2, 5-2] (+1) | SOS: #22 | SOR: #8 | Best Wins: 24-17 vs #20 Alabama | Losses: 14-19 @ Arkansas [6-5], 17-31 @ #10 Georgia | Additional Notes: Trying to avoid getting pimp-walked by Vandy [6-5] this weekend |
12 | Arizona State Sun Devils | [9-2, 6-2] (+9) | SOS: #66 | SOR: #15 | Best Wins: 28-23 vs #13 BYU, 24-14 @ #19 Kansas State | Losses: 22-30 @ Texas Tech [7-4], 14-24 @ Cincinnati [5-6] | Additional Notes: Clinches* Big 12 Title Game Berth with win @ Arizona [4-7] |
13 | BYU Cougars | [9-2, 6-2] (-5) | SOS: #39 | SOR: #13 | Best Wins: 18-15 @ #4 SMU, 38-9 vs #19 Kansas State | Losses: 13-17 vs Kansas [5-6], 23-28 @ #12 Arizona State | Additional Notes: Clinches* Big 12 Title Game Berth with win vs Houston [4-7] and #16 Iowa State loss vs #19 Kansas State |
14 | Clemson Tigers | [9-2, 7-1] (+3) | SOS: #57 | SOR: #18 | Best Wins: 24-20 @ Pittsburgh [7-4] | Losses: 3-34 vs #10 Georgia ("neutral site", Atlanta), 21-33 vs Louisville | Additional Notes: Might be Paper Tigers - can still clinch ACC Title Game Berth with #7 Miami loss @ Syracuse |
15 | South Carolina Gamecocks | [8-3, 5-3] (+4) | SOS: #12 | SOR: #14 | Best Wins: 44-20 vs #22 Texas A&M, 34-30 vs Missouri | Losses: 33-36 vs LSU [7-4], 3-27 vs #18 Ole Miss, 25-27 vs #20 Alabama | Additional Notes: Refs suck |
16 | Iowa State Cyclones | [9-2, 6-2] (+6) | SOS: #69 (nice) | SOR: #17 | Best Wins: 20-19 @ Iowa [7-4] | Losses: 22-23 vs Texas Tech [7-4], 36-45 @ Kansas [5-6] | Additional Notes: Clinch Big 12 Title Game Berth with win vs #19 Kansas State |
17 | Tulane Green Wave | [9-2, 7-0] (+3) | SOS: #100 | SOR: #28 | Best Wins: 35-0 vs Navy [7-3], 41-33 @ Louisiana (Lafayette) | Losses: | Additional Notes: |
18 | Ole Miss Rebels | [8-3, 4-3] (-4) | SOS: | SOR: | Best Wins: | Losses: | Additional Notes: |
19 | Kansas State Wildcats | [8-3, 5-3] (+5) | SOS: | SOR: | Best Wins: | Losses: | Additional Notes: |
20 | Alabama Crimson Tide | [8-3, 4-3] (-7) | SOS: | SOR: | Best Wins: | Losses: | Additional Notes: |
21 | UNLV Rebels | [9-2, 5-1] (+2) | SOS: | SOR: | Best Wins: | Losses: | Additional Notes: |
22 | Texas A&M Aggies | [8-3, 5-2] (-6) | SOS: | SOR: | Best Wins: | Losses: | Additional Notes: |
23 | Army West Point | [9-1, 7-0] (-8) | SOS: | SOR: | Best Wins: | Losses: | Additional Notes: |
24 | Illinois Fighting Illini | [8-3, 5-3] (NEW) | SOS: | SOR: | Best Wins: | Losses: | Additional Notes: |
25 | Colorado Buffaloes | [8-3, 6-2] (-8) | SOS: | SOR: | Best Wins: | Losses: | Additional Notes: |
Teams Ranked:
Rank | Team | Unusualness |
---|---|---|
1 | Oregon Ducks | 0.00 |
2 | Ohio State Buckeyes | 0.00 |
3 | Notre Dame Fighting Irish | 0.27 |
4 | SMU Mustangs | 0.90 |
5 | Texas Longhorns | -0.05 |
6 | Penn State Nittany Lions | 0.00 |
7 | Miami Hurricanes | 0.00 |
8 | Boise State Broncos | 0.00 |
9 | Indiana Hoosiers | 0.00 |
10 | Georgia Bulldogs | -0.67 |
11 | Tennessee Volunteers | 0.00 |
12 | Arizona State Sun Devils | 0.00 |
13 | BYU Cougars | 0.53 |
14 | Clemson Tigers | 0.00 |
15 | South Carolina Gamecocks | 0.00 |
16 | Iowa State Cyclones | 0.00 |
17 | Tulane Green Wave | 0.00 |
18 | Ole Miss Rebels | 0.00 |
19 | Kansas State Wildcats | 0.62 |
20 | Alabama Crimson Tide | -0.24 |
21 | UNLV Rebels | 0.00 |
22 | Texas A&M Aggies | 0.00 |
23 | Army West Point | 0.00 |
24 | Illinois Fighting Illini | 0.00 |
25 | Colorado Buffaloes | 0.00 |
No major omissions.
Total Score: 3.28