Ballot Type: Human
Submitted: Nov. 4, 2024, 9:15 a.m.
Overall Rationale: Each week, I re-rank all teams based on their resumes.
| Rank | Team | Reason | 
|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Oregon Ducks | Oregon is my number 1 team. They are undefeated and have great wins over Ohio State (7-1), Boise State (7-1) as well as nice wins over Illinois (6-3) and Michigan (5-4) | 
| 2 |  BYU Cougars | BYU is undefeated at 8-0. They have a really nice win over SMU (8-1) and also a nice win over Kansas State (7-2). Should be heavy favorites in the rest of their games. | 
| 3 |  Georgia Bulldogs | Georgia is 7-1 with a tough loss to Alabama, but has nice wins over Texas (7-1) and Clemson (6-2) | 
| 4 |  Miami Hurricanes | Miami is undefeated but doesn't have the quality of wins of the teams above them. Best wins are probably Louisville (6-3) and Duke (6-3). | 
| 5 |  Ohio State Buckeyes | Ohio State jumps back up in my poll after a nice win over Penn State (7-1). Only loss is a close one to Oregon. Also have wins over Iowa (6-3) | 
| 6 |  SMU Mustangs | SMU picked up a really nice win this weekend over Pitt (7-1). Also have wins over Louisville (6-3) and Duke (6-3). They've got a good shot at making the ACC title game with Miami. Only loss is a close loss to BYU. | 
| 7 |  Notre Dame Fighting Irish | Notre Dame is 7-1 with a weird loss to Northern Illinois. They have nice wins over Texas A&M (7-2), Louisville, (6-3) and Navy (6-2) | 
| 8 |  Tennessee Volunteers | Tennessee is 7-1 with a nice win over Alabama (6-2). Also have a win over Florida (4-4) | 
| 9 |  Indiana Hoosiers | Indiana is undefeated at 9-0 and has been dominating everyone, but they lack any high quality wins. The best team they've beaten is probably Nebraska (5-4) or Washington (5-4) | 
| 10 |  Texas Longhorns | Texas is 7-1 with wins over Vanderbilt (6-3) and Michigan (5-4) | 
| 11 |  Boise State Broncos | Boise State is 7-1 with a close loss to Oregon. Has nice wins over Washington State (7-1) and UNLV (6-2) | 
| 12 |  Pittsburgh Panthers | Pittsburgh dropped their first game to SMU. They are 7-1. Have a nice win over Syracuse (6-2) and Cincinnati (5-3) | 
| 13 |  Penn State Nittany Lions | Penn State drops to 7-1 with their loss to Ohio State. Best wins are Illinois (6-3) and Wisconsin (5-4) | 
| 14 |  Alabama Crimson Tide | Alabama is 6-2 with a really nice win over Georgia (7-1). Also has a win over Wisconsin (5-4) | 
| 15 |  Texas A&M Aggies | Texas A&M dropped a bit in my poll after a loss to South Carolina. Still 7-2 with good wins over Missouri (6-2) and LSU (6-2) | 
| 16 |  LSU Tigers | LSU is 6-2 with a good win over Ole Miss (7-2) and also a win over South Carolina (5-3) | 
| 17 |  Iowa State Cyclones | Iowa State is 7-1 after losing to Texas tech. Best win is over Iowa (6-3). Also beat Baylor (5-4) and west virginia (4-4) | 
| 18 |  Kansas State Wildcats | Kansas State is 7-2. They have good wins over Colorado (6-2) and Tulane (7-2). Also defeated West Virginia (4-4) | 
| 19 |  Army West Point | Army is 8-0 but lacks quality in their wins. | 
| 20 |  Ole Miss Rebels | Ole Miss is 7-2. Best wins are South Carolina (5-3) and Arkansas (5-4) | 
| 21 |  Missouri Tigers | Missouri is 6-2. Best wins are Vanderbilt (6-3) and Boston College (4-4) | 
| 22 |  Colorado Buffaloes | Colorado is 6-2. Best win is Cincinnati (5-3). Also have a win over Baylor (5-4) | 
| 23 |  Washington State Cougars | Washington State is 7-1 but lacks quality wins. Best wins are Fresno State (5-4) and San Jose State (5-3) | 
| 24 |  Louisville Cardinals | Louisville is 6-3 but has a nice win over Clemson (6-2). All three losses came to teams in my top 10. | 
| 25 |  Clemson Tigers | Clemson takes the final spot in my poll thanks to being 6-2. They lack quality wins. Game vs. Pitt in a few weeks could move them back up. Also considered: Vanderbilt, Iowa, Syracuse, Tulane, and Louisiana. | 
Teams Ranked:
| Rank | Team | Unusualness | 
|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Oregon Ducks | 0.00 | 
| 2 |  BYU Cougars | 0.60 | 
| 3 |  Georgia Bulldogs | 0.00 | 
| 4 |  Miami Hurricanes | 0.00 | 
| 5 |  Ohio State Buckeyes | -0.01 | 
| 6 |  SMU Mustangs | 1.08 | 
| 7 |  Notre Dame Fighting Irish | 0.36 | 
| 8 |  Tennessee Volunteers | 0.00 | 
| 9 |  Indiana Hoosiers | -0.59 | 
| 10 |  Texas Longhorns | -0.66 | 
| 11 |  Boise State Broncos | 0.00 | 
| 12 |  Pittsburgh Panthers | 1.10 | 
| 13 |  Penn State Nittany Lions | -0.83 | 
| 14 |  Alabama Crimson Tide | 0.00 | 
| 15 |  Texas A&M Aggies | 0.00 | 
| 16 |  LSU Tigers | 0.00 | 
| 17 |  Iowa State Cyclones | 0.00 | 
| 18 |  Kansas State Wildcats | 0.52 | 
| 19 |  Army West Point | 0.00 | 
| 20 |  Ole Miss Rebels | -0.15 | 
| 21 |  Missouri Tigers | 2.58 | 
| 22 |  Colorado Buffaloes | 0.00 | 
| 23 |  Washington State Cougars | -0.27 | 
| 24 |  Louisville Cardinals | 0.00 | 
| 25 |  Clemson Tigers | -0.64 |